‘Jali’ as a symbol of syncretic India | New book by Navina Najat Haidar traces the evolution of this intricate lattice work

Jali walls, tomb of Muhammad Ghaus, Gwalior, Madhya Pradesh, c. 1565
| Photo Credit: Abhinav Goswami

In a famous passage in the Koran, as the Prophet Muhammad flees to Medina to escape his enemies, he takes refuge in a cave in Jabal Thawr. As his captors close in, Allah sends one of His “invisible soldiers”, a spider, to protect the future leader of Islam. Blessed by the divine hand, the humble creature, within moments, weaves a thick web to cover the entrance of the hideout, misleading the pursuers into believing it is empty, thereby saving the Prophet’s life.

American art collector and scholar Stuart Cary Welch used to cite this incident as the origin story of the jali, the intricate lattice work decor commonly associated with mosques, palaces and cenotaphs. While it is impossible to ascertain the deific provenance of this architectural marvel, the jali remains ubiquitous across Asia. If you live in a city like Delhi, Ahmedabad, Jaipur or Hyderabad, jalis are everywhere. In fact, simply look around, and you’ll see grilles and meshes, lesser forms of jalis but jalis nonetheless.

Hilal Khan Qazi mosque, Dholka, Gujarat, 1333

Hilal Khan Qazi mosque, Dholka, Gujarat, 1333
| Photo Credit:
Abhinav Goswami

Navina Najat Haidar’s book on jalis is an urgent call to action to save these architectural marvels from neglect

Navina Najat Haidar’s book on jalis is an urgent call to action to save these architectural marvels from neglect

It is from an essay by Mitchell Abdul Karim Crites, another American art historian who has spent over 50 years working with Indian artisans, that we learn about Welch and art collectors like Doris Duke, who played a major role in popularising the jali in the West. Crites’ piece is part of a beautifully designed and richly informative book Jali: Lattice of Divine Light in Mughal Architecture (Mapin Publishing) by Navina Najat Haidar, curator-in-charge of the Department of Islamic Art at New York’s Metropolitan Museum of Art. The piece is one among several tracing the evolution of the jali through time and geographies.

Living traditions

Embellished with vivid photographs by Abhinav Goswami, the book is as much a scholarly work as a vivid reminder of the living traditions that we take for granted or fail to notice. It traces the Roman and Persian origins of the jali, its flourishing as temple art in Gujarat and Vrindavan, restless evolution through the Sultanate era, and eventual apotheosis in the hands of the Mughals. Haidar takes us right up to modern times, where the form gets appropriated and reimagined by artists and architects as distinct as Edwin Lutyens and Mona Hatoum.

Navina Najat Haidar

Navina Najat Haidar

“Each of the patterns in this jali,” Haidar says pointing at the image from Neminath temple in Gujarat, “has a symbolic function.” To my untrained eyes, the squares resemble a code, a cipher to a language we don’t understand any more. In some instances, with jalis in Ibrahim Adil Shah’s tomb in Bijapur, Karnataka, for example, there is indeed a literal calligraphic focus. In some of the arches, Koranic passages are inscribed on jalis, difficult to read unless you are trained, but quite a sight to behold.

An arched jali with seven trees, Sidi Sayyid Mosque, Ahmedabad, Gujarat,

An arched jali with seven trees, Sidi Sayyid Mosque, Ahmedabad, Gujarat,
| Photo Credit:
Abhinav Goswami

Historically, jalis have been put to myriad uses. From acting as a veil between the women of elite families and the outside world, to helping modulate the temperature inside chambers, to directing sunlight at a specific angle on tombs, their functions have evolved depending on the context in which they appeared. Each pattern in the jali repertoire has meanings that are immutable. “The stars and hexagon shapes point to a celestially inspired language,” Haidar says, “while repeating patterns create an illusion of infinity, which, in turn, acts as an allusion to the divine.”

In a striking departure, flowery trellises woven in the style of jalis, which adorn the Krishna temple in Vrindavan, convey a different kind of cosmic message as compared to a jali by a tribal artist in Chhattisgarh. This fluid life of the jali in India’s history and public domain is testament to the syncretic spirit that runs through this country.

The latticed windows of Hawa Mahal, Jaipur

The latticed windows of Hawa Mahal, Jaipur
| Photo Credit:
Abhinav Goswami

The zenith of this tradition was during Shah Jahan’s reign, with jalis surrounded by complex inlay work influenced by the Italian pietra dura style. Scholar Ebba Koch says, since Shah Jahan thought of himself as the “sun king”, the jalis of his time are replete with blooms, nourished by his princely glow. And so, all the flowers of Mumtaz Mahal’s garden house are replicated on her tomb in the Taj Mahal, a reminder of the undying love of her “sun king” and the earthly delights that once filled her heart.

Hidden in plain sight

In spite of its scholarly value, Haidar’s book is an urgent call to all non-historians to pay attention to the beautiful edifices casually strewn across the length and breadth of India, being desecrated by political troublemakers, neglected by bureaucrats, and ignored by citizens. Jali: Lattice of Divine Light in Mughal Architecture opens up a world that readers cannot unsee every time they chance upon a niche in a humble haveli or a latticed window in a famous monument. It also reminds us that though they may be few and far between, we still have among us makers of jalis, keepers of an ancient and specialised knowledge, some of them descendants of the very builders who erected the Taj Mahal.

Floral vase jali, Diwan-i Khas, Agra Fort, c. 1631

Floral vase jali, Diwan-i Khas, Agra Fort, c. 1631
| Photo Credit:
Abhinav Goswami

Recounting a project for the building of a mosque in Malaysia, Crites mentions bringing in retired master builders to train the younger jali-makers. “These elderly master carvers used to sit in the market and drink tea,” he says, “but when we got them to the younger men, they took up the chisel and started teaching them. Their hands were no longer strong enough to do the work, but they knew how to pass on their knowledge.”

Hopefully, books like Haidar’s will humanise the cold, marmoreal elegance of architecture into more intergenerational encounters.

The writer is based in Delhi.

Source link

#Jali #symbol #syncretic #India #book #Navina #Najat #Haidar #traces #evolution #intricate #lattice #work

From militia leader to refugee: The backstory of the man who burned a Koran in Sweden

Soon after a Chrisitan Iraqi man named Salwan Momika burned a Koran in front of Sweden’s largest mosque on June 28, 2023, it was reported that he was a member of a Swedish ultra-nationalist party. Then videos from Momika’s past in Iraq started to surface. This footage showed him wearing the uniform of an Iraqi militia with close links to Iran – a militia that has been accused of war crimes. Momika apparently burned the Koran just a few months after his application for citizenship was denied. 

A Christian man who immigrated from Iraq to Sweden stomped on a Koran then burnt it on June 28, 2023, in front of Stockholm’s largest mosque on the first day of the Muslim holiday of Eid. 

Momika had a friend film the whole scene. He also put slices of ham on the Koran  an act that the Swedish minister for foreign affairs has said amounts to “Islamophobia“. Momika actually applied for permission to carry out his action with the Swedish authorities. And while the police initially banned him, a judge awarded Momika the right to continue on June 23, based on Sweden’s principles of free speech. 

These are screengrabs of the video showing Salwan Momika smiling while burning several pages of the Koran, the sacred book to Muslims. He also says the phrase “Allah Akbar” several times, seemingly making fun of the phrase that means “God is great”. Momika posted the video on his TikTok account on June 29, 2023. Our team has chosen not to republish it. © France 24 Observers

Salwan Momika arrived in Sweden in April 2018. Three years later, in April 2021, he received refugee status, according to information sent to our team by the Swedish Migration Agency, the government body in charge of immigration. Momika has a three-year residency permit (set to expire in April 2024). He lives in the small community of Järna, south of the capital. 

Many Muslims reacted in anger to the incident. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan threatened once again to block Sweden from being able to join NATO. 

Former militia member turned political refugee 

On Facebook, Momika describes himself as an “atheist and enlightened politician, thinker and author”. He is active on many social media sites, especially TikTok and Facebook. However, all of his accounts were created after he had refugee status in Sweden. 

Momika has posted dozens of videos online, often with majority-Muslim country names in Arabic as hashtags. This makes it seem likely that he was trying to stir up as much publicity as possible for his Koran burning. 

 

This is a screengrab of a video published by Momika the night before the fire saying that he had the okay from the Swedish authorities to burn the Koran. He told his followers that they should come see him in front of the grand mosque in Stockholm on the first day of Eid.
This is a screengrab of a video published by Momika the night before the fire saying that he had the okay from the Swedish authorities to burn the Koran. He told his followers that they should come see him in front of the grand mosque in Stockholm on the first day of Eid. © FRANCE 24 Observers

However, since the burning, old videos of Momika have resurfaced and been circulating online, especially amongst the Iraqi immigrant and refugee community in Sweden. Our team verified the videos, which show a group of men, all wearing black t-shirts, carrying the flag of the Imam Ali Brigades, an Iraqi militia with close ties to Iran. 

This is a screengrab of a video that has been circulating on social media since June 29, 2023 that shows Momika seemingly in charge of a group of Christians from Iraq working as part of the Brigades of Imam Ali, a militia with close ties to Iran.
This is a screengrab of a video that has been circulating on social media since June 29, 2023 that shows Momika seemingly in charge of a group of Christians from Iraq working as part of the Brigades of Imam Ali, a militia with close ties to Iran. © FRANCE 24 Observers

Inone video  which has been circulating online since June 29, the day after the Koran burning  Momika says that he is the head of a Christian militia within the Brigades of Imam Ali, an organisation created in 2014 and accused of war crimes.

The original video is unavailable online. However, our team was able to verify this excerpt by seeing two other videos from July 2015 and showing the same scene from a different angle. The first was posted on Facebook by the Faucons des forces syriaques (Falcons of the Syriac forces), a militia and the armed branch of the Syriac Democratic Union party, which was founded by Momika in 2014. The second is a video report from the Lebanese channel MTV, published on Youtube in July 2015.

Momika ran this armed group in the outskirts of Mosul in 2017. However, he was locked in a power struggle with Rayan al-Kaldani, the head of another Christian militia, this one called Babylon, then he ended up leaving Iraq, according to the Arabic-language news site Al Araby Al Jadeed. 

This is a screengrab of a propaganda video published in July 2015 by the YouTube channel “The Voice of the Syriac” with the same set up showing Salwan Momika wearing a uniform and holding a piece of paper in his hand, seemingly getting ready to give a speech.
This is a screengrab of a propaganda video published in July 2015 by the YouTube channel “The Voice of the Syriac” with the same set up showing Salwan Momika wearing a uniform and holding a piece of paper in his hand, seemingly getting ready to give a speech. FRANCE 24 Observers

The Imam Ali Brigades, whose leader has been under US sanctions since 2018, is one of the many groups operating under the umbrella organisation the Popular Mobilization Forces, a group of militias that have been integrated into the Iraq army since 2016 with the aim of fighting against the Islamic State group organisation. All of these militias get logistical and financial support from Iran. 

Videos have circulated online showing members of the Imam Ali Brigades committing atrocities on members of the Islamic State group organisation. 

This photo of Salwan Momika, taken before he arrived in Sweden in April 2018, shows him sitting in his office, holding a kalashnikov and sitting in front of the Aramean (Syriac) flag, which represents an ethnic minority group.
This photo of Salwan Momika, taken before he arrived in Sweden in April 2018, shows him sitting in his office, holding a kalashnikov and sitting in front of the Aramean (Syriac) flag, which represents an ethnic minority group. © FRANCE 24 Observers

When our team contacted the Swedish Migration Agency, they did not want to tell us why they had given Momika asylum. Our team also contacted the Swedish police, who said that they were not able to provide any information because Momika was currently under investigation for “inciting hate”.   

The website of the Swedish Migration Agency says that “persons who have committed certain criminal offences (such as war crimes or other serious crimes), or who pose a threat to the security of Sweden, cannot be granted a residence permit… nor can they be granted asylum under Swedish law”.

While there is no doubt that Momika was part of these militia groups, none of the videos or photos shared online offer proof that he took part in criminal activity.

In a video that began circulating on July 3, 2023, Momika says that his militia had ongoing tensions with other groups within the Popular Mobilization Forces. In the video, he claimed that he was a “victim of the worst acts of torture”, committed by these other groups.   

In an interview with the Swedish newspaper Expressen the day after his Koran burning Momika denied that he had ties to the Popular Mobilization Forces. We reached out to him, but he did not reply to our request for an interview. 

Citizenship application refused

Shortly after his arrival in Sweden, Momika forged links with the Swedish Democrats, a right-wing, ultra-nationalist group, according to an internal document at the Swedish embassy in Baghdad. Hoping to eventually apply for citizenship, Momika supposedly applied for permanent residency, a necessary step in the naturalisation process in Sweden. However, the authorities rejected his request. Authorities said that Momika had been sentenced to community service after having threatened to kill a man while holding a knife.  

Swedish authorities also consider the evolution of the security situation in someone’s home country when making a decision about whether or not to renew someone’s temporary residency permit (Momika’s is set to expire in April 2024).

In a video posted just hours after setting fire to the Koran, Momika criticised Swedish authorities for not providing him with adequate protection. 

This is a screengrab of a video that Momika livestreamed on Instagram after burning the Koran. In the video, he accused Swedish authorities of not providing him with the necessary protection, even though he had faced “international threat.” The video has since been deleted but saved extracts have been circulating on social media.
This is a screengrab of a video that Momika livestreamed on Instagram after burning the Koran. In the video, he accused Swedish authorities of not providing him with the necessary protection, even though he had faced “international threat.” The video has since been deleted but saved extracts have been circulating on social media. © FRANCE 24 Observers

More recent videos posted by Momika show him inside a hotel room. He denied that his actions constituted a hate crime, but said that he would participate in a tribunal.

He also announced his intent to repeat his actions, this time burning the Iraqi flag and the Koran in front of the Iraqi embassy in Stockholm next week.



Source link

#militia #leader #refugee #backstory #man #burned #Koran #Sweden