Carvana vs Wheelzy Comparison: Where Should You Sell Your Car?

DollarBreak is reader-supported, when you sign up through links on this post, we may receive compensation. Disclosure.

The content is for informational purposes only. Conduct your own research and seek advice of a licensed financial advisor. Terms.

Which is Better for Selling the Car?

---

Selling your car with Carvana and Wheelzy is similar in many ways. Both companies charge no fees, offer you same-day payment, and offer free car pick-up services.

Overall, Wheelzy is the better car-buying company to sell your car to. With Wheelzy, you can sell cars that don’t run as well as cars considered to be junk. There is no expiry date on your price offer from Wheelzy, and Wheelzy has much higher customer ratings and experiences in comparison to Carvana.

Carvana vs. Wheelzy Comparison

---

	Carvana	Wheelzy
Cars accepted	New and old cars	New, old, and junk
Fees	No fees	No fees
Requesting quotes	Online	Online
Offer validity	7 days	No expiry
Payments offered	Check, ACH deposit and trade-in	Cash, check
Payout	Same day	Same day
Car pick-up	Free car pick-up	Free car pick-up
Physical locations	Various physical locations	Nationwide locations
Turnaround time	Same day	Same day
Customer service	Text, online chat, phone	Online chat, phone
Reviews	2.7	4.8

Cars Accepted

---

Carvana will accept both new and used cars that are in drivable conditions. With Carvana, there are additional requirements:

• The car must have a working odometer
• Must pass a safe drive test
• Car must be manufactured after 1992

Wheelzy accepts any car in the US regardless of the make, model, or condition. Wheelzy will buy wrecked cars, or those considered junk cars that no longer run. 

Fees

---

Carvana and Wheelzy both provide you with a free quote when you fill out an application form online. Neither companies charge any fees for selling your car.

Requesting Quotes

---

Both Carvana and Wheelzy offer free instant quotes after you fill out their application online. 

With Wheelzy, you will be asked to include:

• Make and model
• Year of manufacturing
• Sub model
• Car zip code
• Phone number

With Carvana, you will need to include:

• Make and model
• Year of manufacturing
• VIN code
• Mileage
• Color
• Zipcode
• Loan status
• Mechanical issues
• Accident history
• Premium features
• General condition

Offer Validity

---

With Carvana, your offer is valid for 7 days upon receiving it. There is no specified expiry date for offers with Wheelzy. Wheelzy promises to keep offer amounts available as long as they are able to.

Payments Offered

---

If you sell your car with Carvana, they will provide you with a check in hand on the day you bring your car into one of their dealership location and make the sale. 

You may also choose to accept Carvana or DriveTime’s trade-in option, where you can bring your car to the dealership to make a trade.

With Wheelzy, when one of their car removal experts comes to pick up your car, they will offer you payment in the form of a check or cash.

Payout

---

Since Carvana hands you a check on the spot, this means that you will get paid immediately. A check will usually take up to 2 business days to clear however, some checks make take longer to clear and show up in your bank account.

With Wheelzy, you will receive cash or a check on the date you agreed upon for a car specialist to come and pick up your car.

Car Pick-up

---

Carvana and Wheelzy both offer free car pick-up services. Carvana representatives will run a quick inspection to ensure that the car’s condition matches the description you submitted in your application. 

If everything checks out, you will get the agreed-upon amount for your vehicle. If something does not match your description, the company may change its offer. Carvana only accepts accident-free cars, which means your offer may be rejected if the inspector finds any proof of accident.

Wheelzy accepts all kinds of cars and offers free pick-up services.

Physical Locations

---

Carvana has 33 Carvana Vending Machines nationwide where you can drop off your vehicle and pick up a new one. 

Wheelzy has physical locations all across the United States.

Turnaround Time

---

Both Carvana and Wheelzy offer a quick turnaround time for quoting and buying your car from you. It typically takes 24 hours to sell your car with both dealerships as quoting and selling your car can be done all on the same day.

Customer Service

---

With Carvana, you can contact customer service at 800-333-4554. You can contact Wheelzy’s customer service by calling 855-294-0940 or by accessing the online chat feature on their website.

Reviews

---

On Trustpilot, Carvana has a 2.7-star rating, while the overall rating for Wheelzy is 4.8-stars on Trustpilot. Carvana does not have any rating on BBB, while Wheelzy has a 3-star rating on BBB.

	Carvana	Wheelzy
Trustpilot Rating	2.7	4.8
BBB Rating		3

Customers have praised Carvana for providing fair price offers and quick selling services, as well as for providing excellent customer service. Some customers have raised complaints about the selling process being complicated, Carvana providing the wrong payment, and not honoring their price offers.

Customers have left positive reviews about Wheelzy for being on time for pick-up, staying in touch with customers throughout the selling process, and for providing a smooth transaction. Customers have complained about the tow drivers coming late, Wheelzy not honoring the original price-offer, and tow drivers not showing up at all.

Carvana & Wheelzy Alternatives

---

Peddle

Peddle purchases all types of cars including used cars, and even what some would consider junk like Wheelzy.

Like with Carvana and Wheelzy, Peddle provides you with an instant quote after you submit an online application form through their website. After receiving your offer, you will have 7 days to consider and accept the offer. Peddle offers to send a representative to pick up or tow your car for free like with Carvana and Wheelzy. 

As with Carvana and Wheelzy, Peddle will hand you a check on the same day of the sale. In comparison to Carvana and Wheelzy, Peddle has high reviews on both Trustpilot and BBB, with a 4.7-star rating on Trustpilot, and a 4.7-star rating on BBB.

eBay Motors

With eBay Motors, you create your listing yourself, set the price, deliver the car once it is sold, and change the title yourself. eBay Motors also charges an insertion fee when you create a listing and a successful listing fee when your vehicle is sold, while Wheelzy and Carvana do not charge extra fees.

Carvana and Wheelzy are companies that will buy your car from you by providing you a price offer, and picking up or towing your car for free. You don’t have to create or manage any listings with either of these companies.

eBay Motors has a 4-star rating on Consumer Affairs while Carvana has a 2.6-star rating, and Wheelzy does not have any rating on the platform.